.
Feedback

Why Does the Hopkins School District Cover So Many Cities?

A look at how Hopkins’ boundaries came about may add context to a debate over whether some Edina residents should be able to leave the district.

Even though districts are typically named after one of the cities they serve, they are separate entities, legally distinct from those cities.

Hopkins Public Schools covers all of Hopkins, most of Minnetonka, half of Golden Valley and parts of Eden Prairie, Edina, Plymouth and St. Louis Park. Those boundaries reflect numerous votes and agreements between school districts and residents in the past.

This week, the Hopkins School Board will examine the latest in a long line of boundary change requests. A group of Edina residents in the Parkwood Knolls and Walnut Drive neighborhoods wants to leave Hopkins because they think its schools are not in locations that serve the families’ educational needs.

In preparation for the School Board’s vote Thursday, district administrators prepared a history of the district’s boundaries. That history showcases how a district named after a four-square-mile community grew into a 7,400-student entity covering a swathe of the west metro.

“Paramount in this process was local initiative and study, with the approval by legal entities—local school boards and subsequent referendum elections by the voters of each of the Common and/or Independent School Districts involved,” district administrators wrote in the report for the Thursday’s meeting.

Here’s a look at how Hopkins grew into what it is today, according to that report. Refer to the images above to see the areas being referenced.

***

Timeline

Early decades

1898: Harley Hopkins Independent School District (ISD) No. 135 is established

  • Added portions of West Minneapolis (Hopkins), Edina and Minnetonka

1898: Hopkins ISD No. 19 is established

  • Added parts of West Minneapolis and Minnetonka Township
  • Prior to that, Hopkins was a common school district with a two-story, four-room school

1946: Glen Lake Common District No. 155 votes to dissolve and join Hopkins ISD No. 19

  • Added parts of Hopkins, Minnetonka and Eden Prairie

1946: Shady Oak Common District No. 97 votes to dissolve and join Hopkins

  • Added parts of Minnetonka, Eden Prairie and Edina

 

After the Minnesota reorganization law

In 1947, the Legislature passed a law to reorganization law designed to encourage districts to start talking about combining. Minnesota went from 7,679 districts in 1945 to 2,148 districts in 1963, when the first mandatory reorganization legislation further reduced the number of districts.

1950: A vote to combine Oak Knoll Common School District, Burwell Common School District, Harley Hopkins and Hopkins fails when Harley Hopkins voters reject the idea.

1952: Harley Hopkins and Hopkins vote to consolidate, forming Independent School District No. 225.

  • Added parts of Hopkins, Edina and Minnetonka.

1953: Burwell and Hopkins vote to consolidate. A small part of Burwell goes to the Wayzata school district.

  • Added parts of Minnetonka and Hopkins

1954: Oak Knoll votes to consolidate

  • Added parts of Minnetonka and St. Louis Park.

1955: Westview Common School District No. 138 votes to consolidate with Hopkins

  • Added parts of Plymouth and Golden Valley.

1961: The commissioner of education changes Hopkins to District No. 274

1980: Golden Valley Independent District No. 275 dissolves and merges with Hopkins. The new district is designated District No. 270—the designation the district has today.

  • Added a part of Golden Valley.
J. Bergman December 18, 2012 at 06:51 pm
The Hopkins school board members will have some answering to do if they vote against the request (and in favor of continuing to collect $500,000 per year from Parkwood Knolls residents for the education of only 9 Parkwood Knolls children).
I believe the Hopkins school board members should let go of their "hostage neighborhood", and move on in a positive direction.
J. Bergman December 18, 2012 at 06:56 pm
Reviewing the timeline, along with an historical aerial map, shows that the Parkwood Knolls area was only farm fields and a couple houses at the time it was added to the Hopkins school district. According to previous Patch articles, there are now around 400 families in this area.
Since most people will look at the timeline, but not an historical, aerial map, they will be deceived into thinking that, at one time, residents of the area in question CHOSE to join the Hopkins school district through a democratic process. Perhaps the purpose of the timeline is just that (an effort on the part of the Hopkins school board to deceive rather than clarify).
James Warden (Editor) December 18, 2012 at 07:13 pm
Or it may show — as one of the Unite Edina leaders pointed out at the CFAC meeting — that Hopkins has already seen its share of boundary changes. The relevance of those changes depends on one's interpretation.
J. Bergman December 18, 2012 at 07:38 pm
All the actions mentioned in the timeline increased the size of the district (or in one case, left it the same). Yet the district size has never decreased. It seems that, if neighborhoods can be added to the district, there should also be some way for them to be subtracted. There is a precedence for boundary changes, but unfortunately Hopkins has never seen "its share" of any reductions. (In fact, it has never allowed a reduction.)
J. Bergman December 18, 2012 at 08:45 pm
Earlier, I pointed-out that the Time-line is deceptive. It deceives people into thinking that, in the past, residents of Parkwood Knolls, chose to be part of the Hopkins school district, as part of a democratic process.
It appears that "The Patch" was also deceived into believing this. The article quotes anonymous Hopkins "district administrators" as essentially saying this. After I pointed-out that the time-line is deceptive, "The Patch" submitted a comment stating that perhaps the real point of the time-line had been to show that Hopkins had already experienced "its share" of boundary changes. This seems to be "Monday-morning quarterbacking" at its best. (Besides, saying that Hopkins has already experienced "its share" of changes makes it sound like Hopkins merely tolerated these changes, when really it proposed, encouraged and voted for these size increases.) It's hard to believe that one has been deceived. Yet, even reporters for the "New York Times" are sometimes deceived, as they have acknowledged whenever this occurs. I only hope that reporters at "The Patch" will realize that the Hopkins school board has deceived them multiple times, and they tend to take the bait "hook, line and sinker."
James Warden (Editor) December 19, 2012 at 03:17 am
You misunderstand me. I wasn't saying that's why the school district had included the timeline. I was merely pointing out a way that a Unite Edina supporter interpreted the same information at an earlier meeting. I thought it added an interesting take on the information under discussion.
And if you think there's something I left out — or haven't covered or want to elaborate on — I invite you to share your thoughts on a Patch blog. This is a community site, after all. I love to have a variety of voices discussing the issues important to the community. Residents like you can provide way more information and opinions than any single journalist could hope to do. If you — or anyone else, on either side of the issue — is interested, just go here: http://hopkins.patch.com/blog/apply Like I said, I love hearing whatever residents have to say. Patch's whole goal is to foster dialog and community engagement.
David Abrams December 19, 2012 at 01:21 pm
Hey- we have open enrollment. Folks can send their kids to whatever school they want and the bring their state aid dollars with them. Edina wants more tax dollars for their schools and it is a zero sum game. Hopkins offers excellent education in a school district with a cosmopolitan mix of race, color, and economic diversity. Edina offers excellent education in a school district that is largely white and wealthy. Folks can choose what they want for their kids already. Annexation from one district to the other doesn't do anything but shift a very limited resource from one district to another. No net gain for the state or the community at large. From an historical perspective, maybe Edina didn't much care about Parkwood Knolls when the decision was made back in the day - not much tax revenue from a farm.
Sheri December 19, 2012 at 02:14 pm
I would like to point out that many of the areas that ended up in the Hopkins School District were also farms. If all of those areas used your argument to allow them to disconnect, the District would be hugely different.
The Hopkins School District is an amazing set of schools at all levels and I feel blessed that my children have an opportunity to not only come out highly educated but have also had many opportunities to witness how our Global Society is. There is great value in being in a learning environment of cultural and socioeconomic diversity. Ultimately, your child's education comes down to what you are also willing to put into it as a parent. The beauty of Open Enrollment allows you to send your child somewhere else if you do not agree with the system. I am hopeful that the district will make the right decision and NOT allow this annexation.
James Warden (Editor) December 19, 2012 at 03:50 pm
Y'all may be interested in this story just published:
http://hopkins.patch.com/articles/what-role-does-wealth-play-in-edina-request-to-leave-hopkins-schools Take a look at the demographics and share your thoughts: Are they even relevant to the discussion?
Betty Johnson December 19, 2012 at 03:58 pm
And there's a reason the school district boundaries are so jagged. The Common or Independent Districts were formed by combining adjacent areas served by one-room schools. Residents on the edges of a new district could choose if they wanted to join it or not. They lived on properties of varying sizes, ranging from farms over 100 acres to five or ten acre homesteads. Even if they were all rectangular-shaped, putting them together often resulted in an irregular-shaped school district.
Betty J
F. Anderson December 19, 2012 at 05:28 pm
As a resident of Minnetonka who resides in the Hopkins school district, I am surprised at Edina's latest argument over how special they are. Maybe all of us in Minnetonka should get together and use Edina's argument, that we should have the right for our children to attend schools in the city in which they live? If fact, maybe every city should say the same thing? Let's call it what it is, and what they just won't say....Edina thinks that Hopkins schools aren't up to the standards of the people living there, although they are fine for everyone else beneath them, so they want out so they can all be part of their own little exclusive club.
David F December 19, 2012 at 11:55 pm
Interesting name calling and community bashing. I have lived in 2 school districts in the Twin Cities and both times where I lived was based on the district and elementary school that my children would attend. It sometimes gets lost in this discussion but some Edina schools are full and are not eligible for open enrollment. Edina is actually seeing an influx of new children due to the mass house tear downs going on in Edina, 100 this year.

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Hopkins Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
James Warden (Editor) June 17, 2013 at 05:44 pm
For those who need some help dealing with coyotes, here are some tips from a national expert whoRead More visited the west metro in March: http://stlouispark.patch.com/groups/around-town/p/coyote-tips
Cathi Hansen June 18, 2013 at 01:13 pm
What area of Hopkins? That might help narrow down the area to look in....
Mary Ellen Dower June 8, 2013 at 10:48 am
I will be there too with knit baby sweaters, hats and ponchos! Mary Ellen Knits Gifts
Mary Ellen Dower June 8, 2013 at 11:13 am
And wool felted slippers too! Mary Ellen Knits Gifts
Orono June 7, 2013 at 02:29 pm
NOOOOOOOOOOOOOO This guy is closer to communist than he is to democrat.
Orono May 21, 2013 at 08:53 pm
Mike B. The liberal belief system puts the job of caring for the needy on the government. JesusRead More said, love thy neighbor as thy self. I do a very poor job of loving my neighbor but the one thing I do try and do is give back. My wife and I give between 15 and 17% every year. We have been blessed with financial success and try keep that in mind every day. Also though, we give ourselves. Giving yourself to a cause is better (in my opinion) than just giving money. We give money because we can, we give our time because we should. I have a few liberal friends working beside me for our causes but, in general, the majority of us are all conservatives. Mark Dayton is a classic example of how the liberal mind works. Give the government the money, let them deal with those losers.
Mike B. June 1, 2013 at 03:29 pm
The Democrats are 100% responsible for increasing poverty in the state. Dayton and his DemocratRead More lackeys and cronies are driving out all of the job producers in Minnesota with their socialist, anti-business policies.
Sue June 5, 2013 at 09:14 am
Consider this- the (unelected) Met Council controls everything from parks, to trails, to transit, toRead More waste water. If a city wants to do anything they have to work with the Met Council and one of the FAVORITE expectations is that cities ADD "AFFORDABLE" or - Section 8 housing. While the recession hit the suburbs hard - the biggest influx or poor - are the indigenous poor into free housing
mike savick June 9, 2013 at 09:46 am
"Mike B" continues to look in the mirror and post about others. Emails show the Mr.Read More Hindin offered to produce his Minnesota drivers license at any west metro police station. The compulsively dishonest Mike B thing declined.
Michael Hindin June 9, 2013 at 10:03 am
Mike B. posted June 8, 2013 at 08:58 pm "The best one can hope for is that the jewishRead More (sic)person and the muslim (sic) will tolerate one another. Hard to tell what side is most at fault. Can't say I trust either one.... neither has what we would call Western Civilization values. "......NEITHER HAS WHAT WE WOULD CALL WESTERN CIVILIZATION VALUES"??? (Capitalization for emphasis) Without the contributions of Jews and Arab Muslims you would be still in the Dark Ages worshiping golden cows and there wouldn't be your version of "western civilization" Do I really have to remind you of a Jewish carpenter. Bearing false witness is prohibited by all Abrahamic religions.
Corinne June 10, 2013 at 05:25 pm
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Name_calling
Orono June 3, 2013 at 02:18 pm
I totally agree with both points. Republicans have zero business deciding social issues. Democrats,Read More as Mark Dayton just proved, have zero business deciding important adult decisions that deal with finances and taxes.
Dan Johnson June 12, 2013 at 07:07 pm
Orono. You seem to assume my on-line fight for equal rights is a reflection of my entire life. ItRead More isn't. I've missed a few days, as I was kayak camping, without electronics. It also seems you are repeating the mistake of comparing atrocities, and then dismissing as irrelevant the one that seems less severe. This misses the point that no atrocities are acceptable. As I have stated repeatedly, all religions, as well as non-religious belief systems, promote the Golden Rule. Different sects of all of those religions also find excuses to ignore it. No matter what the belief system claimed as an excuse for anti-gay prejudice, refusing to treat others as you would yourself is a violation of every major ethical belief system, as well as a violation of the promise of equality in our founding documents and required by the constitution. Any person who espouses any belief system that requires hating and harming others, has earned the label of "hater". Having a belief system is not a virtue when it requires harming others. Yet, again, not all prejudice requires hate. It may be a result of a lack of careful consideration of the information, or simply a distrust of others who seem different in some way.
Dan Johnson June 12, 2013 at 07:08 pm
Orono. You said: "I hate liberalism." We have stated you are free to hate if and as youRead More want. But neither you, me, nor MB should be allowed to use hate as a justification for refusing to treat others as you would yourself under the law. MB makes it clear, he would use the law to harm all gay people severely, based on his hate.
Dan Johnson June 12, 2013 at 07:28 pm
Donald. Again, you resort to mischaracterizing Joyce's comment in order to support your desire toRead More reinstate discrimination in the public square. Tyrannies result when discrimination based on your choice of being offended, is allowed under the law. This is the reason the Golden Rule is found in every major ethical belief system as well as a requirement of our system of government. Your desire to harm others based on your personal beliefs, does not extend to the public square. Again, segregation is only one of many examples of the atrocities that result when prejudice and discrimination are enshrined in the law. As you said yourself, the law is needed for protection of equal rights when someone is offended, not when they are not.
Mike B. June 9, 2013 at 07:17 pm
Sure Susan, attack the conservatives. If you comment in the Minneapolis Red Star, you'll getRead More published, as they smear patriotic, Christian Americans, and give liberals a free ride.
Susan June 9, 2013 at 07:25 pm
Mike B., you must really be bored if you had to come back to this... I attack the ideology andRead More people that want to decide for everyone how they should live their lives. You know, those who would condemn or persecute those wanting something different that, BTW, is granted to them by way of living in a free country. It's time to try some new material, Mike, this is really getting old and tired.
fb.com/WCwatchdog June 16, 2013 at 03:42 am
I ride a sport bike... can I also have 130 miles of track to ride on in Woodbury like the bikers?...Read More oh wait... that's right, I have to put my bike in my truck, drive 130 miles to the nearest track, pay $150 in track fees, just to ride... Bicyclists, you don't know how good you have it with your completely free paved bike paths.
Michael Hindin May 23, 2013 at 12:48 pm
Simple answer G Wright is that "Mike B" manufactures it. IT has PATCH history ofRead More compulsive dishonesty.
Michael Hindin May 23, 2013 at 01:02 pm
People in general have a very difficult time discussing race. I nave gone to interestingRead More presentations sponsored by the St Paul Foundation. (https://www.facingrace.org/) Good people who are trying to understand are often afraid of saying the wrong thing. It takes a lot of patience and tolerance to engage in this conversation. It is often difficult to realize that even though many of our generation did not set up the situation, there are still many advantages built into being in the racial majority and change is painful.
Dan Johnson June 4, 2013 at 10:23 am
The divide of race has been America's constant curse. Each new wave of immigrants gives new targetsRead More to old prejudices. Prejudice and contempt, cloaked in the pretense of religious or political conviction, are no different. They have nearly destroyed us in the past. They plague us still. They fuel the fanaticism of terror. They torment the lives of millions in fractured nations around the world. These obsessions cripple both those who are hated and, of course, those who hate, robbing both of what they might become.” Bill Clinton
rob_h78 April 16, 2013 at 10:56 pm
After reading the comment from "RP45241", I went to www.greatschools.com and looked upRead More Washburn High School vs Wayzata High School (that is in Plymouth) and was shocked. These kids really gotta study more and they need every minute possible to study - they literally cannot afford a minute of not being in a classroom learning. http://www.greatschools.org/minnesota/minneapolis/1320-Washburn-Senior-High-School/?tab=test-scores http://www.greatschools.org/minnesota/plymouth/2228-Wayzata-High-School/?tab=test-scores Just a few examples of percentage of students meeting\exceeding standards: Math: Washburn 41% Wayzata 81% State Average 58% Reading: Washburn: 67% Wayzata 94% State Average 77% Science: Washburn 40% Wayzata 77% State Average 52% Yikes!!!
Jim Flaherty April 17, 2013 at 12:10 pm
Shame on the school district. It seems that one person is under investigation for possible misdoingsRead More and a bunch of students protest the possibility of his termination by skipping school. When the Principal follows policy and marks the protesters records with an unexcused absence she gets reassigned (fired). What the school should have taught the students is that the person under investigation is in a Union and will most likely be fine unless that person really messed up. That the Principal is not in a Union and will most likely loss her job for doing the correct thing, because the union has more power than the school district. What a lesson to teach, do the wrong thing and get rewarded and do the right thing and get punished. Good job Washburn.
Heyitsme April 17, 2013 at 07:21 pm
Skipping is skipping and unexcused absences are unexcused absences; protest after or before school.Read More That is what we did. (on the public sidewalk, so the school couldn't say they are trespassing). We had a favorite bus driver that was fired by the school board for a really stupid reason (it has been over 30 years ago) and students were upset and we protested before and after school. If you were not where you were supposed to be by the time class started you were marked down as unexcused absence. Teachers have a job to do and students have a job to do. Free speech is still allowed but operate under the school (and state) education rules.